Who has the best pizza in Westchester, NY?

May 26th, 2022 by

New Yorkers know pizza. Just look around, and you can find New York-style pizza all over the world. But what are the best local places to get the classic crust and toppings you love? We’ve put together a list of our favorite places for pizza in Westchester with mouthwatering suggestions to help you order the best pie in town.

Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana

Founded in 1925 by Frank Pepe himself, an Italian immigrant from Naples, Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana offers pizzas steeped in tradition. After opening a bakery together, Pepe’s wife, Filomena, added a little-known dish from Naples to the menu. You can still order the tomato pie with mozzarella and olive oil, the original pizza that started it all. Try another menu favorite, the white clam pizza, likely inspired by the fresh littleneck clams served as an appetizer. The veggie special also packs the good for your toppings with broccoli, mushrooms, spinach, onions, and peppers.

Location: 1955 Central Park Ave., Yonkers, New York

Phone number: 914-961-8284

Venice Pizza and Trattoria

With homemade dough and fresh ingredients sourced locally, Venice Pizza and Trattoria is a local favorite with unique pies combining pasta and traditional Italian dishes into a pizza. Take the eggplant parmigiana pizza with slices of grilled eggplant covered in melted mozzarella over a crispy crust. The penne pasta vodka pizza features a savory vodka tomato sauce and cheese. They also serve Grandma-style pizzas, a thin, rectangular pie said to have originated in Long Island and modeled after the rustic pizzas Italian homemakers made. Try the chicken marsala pizza or bacon chicken ranch for a more modern take on pizza.

Location: 731 N. Broadway, North White Plains, New York

Phone number: 914-615-9460

Amore Pizzeria and Italian Kitchen

The menu at Amore Pizzeria and Italian Kitchen gives diners a lot of choices for crusts, toppings, and sauce. With cauliflower and gluten-free crust options, its traditional and artisan pizzas offer a taste for everybody. Order the diavola with red chili flakes and spicy soppressata for a fiery pie. Hungry for a classic? Taste its chicken Parm pizza with chicken breast, tomato, and mozzarella. Bianchi (no red sauce) pizzas also come in flavors like the old country, with roasted zucchini, cherry tomatoes, roasted garlic, black olives, and mushrooms, or the Arthur Avenue Special, with fennel sausage and sauteed broccoli rabe.

Location: 1 Kent Place, Armonk, New York

Phone number: 914-273-3535

The Parlor

The Parlor offers wild flavor creations in wood-fired pizzas. For instance, the everything bagel features Parmesan and mozzarella cheeses topped with everything bagel seasoning and a fresh egg. Or there’s the lemonator, which has smoked provolone, chili, and cured lemons. Offering an impressive list of both red and white pizzas, this taste-forward pizza joint elevates the traditional pie. Lunch items differ slightly with some pizzas that only show up for afternoon diners, like the Sunday salad and calzone.

Location: 14 Cedar St., Dobbs Ferry, New York

Phone number: 914-478-8200

Fortina Pizza

Fortina Pizza’s eye-catching menu lists some intriguing names for their pies. Enjoy gourmet ingredients on a unique pie crafted by their pizza chefs with specials like the Don Freddy. with delicata squash, chilies, bacon, and fontina cheese. Try the Funghi e salumi topped with wild mushrooms, provolone, and finocchiona. Get real fancy with the LB, which features black truffle, robiolona, burrata, and Parmesan. Fortina also offers cooking classes to unleash your inner pizza chef for friends and family.

Location: 136 S. Ridge St., Rye Brook, New York

Phone number: 914-937-0900


Abatino’s may not have the most extensive pizza menu on our list, but what it has is sure to please a discerning pizza lover. Its traditional pan pizza features chopped garlic, fresh tomatoes, and mozzarella on a thin crust. Other tasty choices include the salad pizza, which basically offers everything you’d find on a crispy romaine salad, from cucumber to olives and even house dressing, or the chicken barbeque pizza with red onions and a tangy sauce. It also offers a clam scampi pizza topped with baby clams and white wine.

Location: 670 N. Broadway, White Plains, New York

Phone number: 914-686-0380

Roma’s Restaurant

Roma’s serves classic thin crust brick oven pizza with traditional, square Sicilian and a variety of specialty pies. For something new, try the mixed green salad pie with mesclun greens, tomatoes, red onion, and shaved Parmesan topped with balsamic vinaigrette. Or taste the Roma special with sausage, peppers, anchovies, mushrooms, and garlic. Its grandpa pizza inverts cheese and sauce, adding the mozzarella first, then topping it with tomatoes, garlic, and extra pecorino Romano.

Location: 29 Columbus Ave., Tuckahoe, New York

Phone number: 914-961-3175

Colony Grill

While Colony Grill may not sound like a pizza place, it serves up some truly unique Irish-style pies. Its sparse menu lets you choose from uncommon toppings, like hot oil and stingers, to craft your own special pizza. Its breakfast pies feature your choice of bacon or sausage with egg and cheese. The salad pie comes with mixed greens topped with crispy veggies and a balsamic vinaigrette. Colony Grill serves up pizzas with a signature thin crust sprinkled with sea salt and oil.

Location: 35 Abendroth Ave., Port Chester, New York

Phone number: 914-934-2428

Pizzeria LaRosa

Cooked in a 100-year-old restored wood-fire oven, the pies at Pizzeria LaRosa are handcrafted with fresh ingredients. When owners Matt DiGesu and Frank Pinello heard the story of this vintage restaurant in the heart of New Rochelle, they revived it as a local spot. Their simple pizza menu offers options for veggie-forward pies like the fried eggplant or meat-lover specials like the vodka pizza with smoked bacon. LaRosa also makes a vegan Margherita pizza with vegan cheese.

Location: 12 Russel Ave., New Rochelle, New York

Phone number: 914-633-0800

Like our list or have a suggestion of your own? Let us know so that we can get the list right. Just like the best pizza spots in town at Bill Volz Westchester, our selection of new and pre-owned vehicles gives you great options to buy or trade. Next time you’re in the area to satisfy your pizza craving, feel free to stop in to meet our staff and find the ride of your dreams.

Posted in Local